The Student Loan Bubble Explained

by Chase Donnally

There is currently more than $900 billion of outstanding student loan debt held in the United States, more than any other type of debt held by Americans. Nearly 60% of all students must borrow money to help cover the costs of their college education each year, and that number is sure to increase as the price of education continues to rise.

Student loan debt cannot be erased through bankruptcy, and if you default on your payments, the government can garnish your wages, unemployment benefits, tax refunds, and even social security to make up the payments. Many recently graduated students owe more than $28,000 on their student loans, and often have degrees that don’t open up doors to very high paying jobs. And with the price of a college education on the rise, things are only looking to get worse.

Tuition and fees in the UC System have increased by more than 50% since 2008. If it were not for the ability to take out student loans, it would seem that a large portion of college students would be unable to keep up with increasing costs and would have to drop out of school. So should we be singing the praises of government assistance, or could this be an example of government breaking your legs and handing you crutches? That is to say, could the federal student loans program actually be a major contributing factor to the rapidly increasing costs of higher education in the United States?

The federal student loans program provides students with low-interest loans that would otherwise be difficult for prospective students to obtain. The loan standards for these loans are practically non-existent to make sure that young future students are able to qualify. You don’t need to have any significant credit history or source of income, so for most students the only way they’ll be able to pay off their loans is if they land a good job after they graduate.

In economic terms, what the government is doing is extending a cheap line of credit to students, with interest rates below the actual market value. This expansion of credit makes college appear to be a better investment than it actually is, and artificially increases demand in higher education. This artificial increase in demand (specifically, an increase in the ability to pay) leads to schools raising their prices over time. In normal market conditions, these increases in price would decrease demand, and lead to students dropping out; but because students are able to get cheap loans from the government, they are able to pay the increasing costs.

This fact has not been lost on universities; they are well aware that they can continue to increase tuition costs without reductions in revenue coming as a result of students dropping out. This ability of schools to increase tuition rates indefinitely ultimately benefits schools and is detrimental to students.

Does the situation above sound familiar? It should. We recently experienced a very similar bubble in the housing market, which eventually led to the crash in 2008. The root cause was the same: an expansion of credit, this time by the Federal Reserve, and various legislation meant to increase home ownership, leading to increasing home prices.

Unfortunately, the increasing prices could not be sustained forever. Eventually, when the mortgage default rate became too high, the bubble started to collapse, and we experienced the crash and the resultant recession. The Student Loan Bubble, as it has come to be called, will experience the same collapse when the default rate of student loans reaches an unsustainable point. As it stands, the default rate is already quite high at nearly 9%.

Those graduates who are unable to pay face their wages, tax refunds, and unemployment benefits being garnished, which has led to calls for student loan debt to be forgiven by the government. While this no doubt sounds like the perfect panacea to those students in default, it will likely only worsen the inevitable crash. If the loans were forgiven, that would mean a loss of nearly one trillion dollars in projected revenue to those holding the debt, which will almost inevitably result in another major government bailout.

The resulting increase in the government debt will only hasten us toward a sovereign debt crisis like those being experienced in the Eurozone.

The student loan bubble is a looming disaster, but not one that can be solved by more expansion of credit, government spending, or inflationary policies. The best possible solution, while it sounds unappealing and painful, would be to phase out the student loans program. Colleges would be forced to either lower their prices in order to accommodate those students unable to pay the currently outrageous fees, or face a dropout rate of more than 50% and the massive reduction in revenue that would go along with it.

It would certainly not be painless, but the damage is already done, and any attempts to avert the hangover will simply serve to put it off until later, when it will be much worse.

The economist Ludwig von Mises summarized this quite well in his magnum opus, Human Action, when he said, “There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as the result of voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as a final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved.”

Given those options, the better choice seems pretty obvious.

About these ads

22 comments

  1. Student loans are both unsecured debt and the modern form of indentured servitude.

  2. What is being missed is the perspective of the student or parent.
    For parents college attendance creates the illusion of productivity and success for their children. They are all for it as long as they don’t believe they are paying the bills.
    Most students view college as a ‘life experience’ rather than a financial investment. They are perfectly happy to charge their women’s studies and classics courses on the invisible government credit card.
    Typically the kids graduate with no prospects and move back in at which point the parents get to play the victims and soak up sympathy.
    But really, i wonder how a pizza tastes that isn’t delivered by a college graduate?

  3. “Power Does What It Wants.” – George Carlin… http://vimeo.com/50460060

  4. nice, you made mention of von mises.

    the sooner the government gets out of student loan regulations, the sooner lending institutions can go back to proper risk assessment. If they don’t regardless? don’t bail them out. the threat of bankruptcy is quite the regulation

  5. Heya fantastic blog! Does running a blog such as this require a great deal
    of work? I’ve no understanding of coding however I was hoping to start my own blog in the near future. Anyways, should you have any suggestions or tips for new blog owners please share. I understand this is off topic however I just needed to ask. Appreciate it! nutrition

  6. I was very happy to discover this great
    site. I need to to thank you for ones time for this particularly fantastic read!
    ! I definitely liked every bit of it and i also have you saved to fav
    to check out new information on your site.
    fat loss workouts

  7. Yes! Finally something about healthy diet snacks.
    diets that work

  8. Nice blog here! Also your site loads up fast! What host
    are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host?
    I wish my website loaded up as fast as yours lol Elida

  9. If you want to grow your familiarity just keep visiting this site and be updated with the most recent news update posted here.

  10. Thank you for every other informative website. Where else may just Iam getting
    thawt type of info written in such an ideal manner? I’ve
    a challenge that I am just now operating on, and I have been at the look out for such information.

  11. I must than yoou for the efforts you’ve put in
    writing this website. I’m hoping to view the same high-grade blog posts from you in thhe future aas well.

    In fact, yyour creative writing abilities hass motivated me to get mmy very ownn site
    now ;)

  12. Howdy! This article could not be written any better! Going through ths article reminds me oof my previous roommate!
    He constantly kept preaching about this. I willl send this post to
    him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!

  13. Hi, after rezding this amazing piede of writing i am too happy to shre my experience hrre witgh mates.

  14. Since a lot of fans can’t spend the money for unique gorgeous jewelry fashion trends
    of the stars they look for the everyday costume jewelry that come with the same
    designs and styles. Do not forget the selection of
    shoes to go along with with your attire. Although
    Herve Leger has a lot of different colors, stars may
    wear the same dress to attend the same ceremony, which is quite embarrassing.

    And also the integral part of looks can be dressing.
    Many eligible candidates are choosing the bank jobs over others because working in a bank is considered as safe and secure for many people.
    However, motherhood brings regarding a lot of physical changes
    in the body within the time of conception plus throughout pregnancy.
    Violet Affleck really looks like her mother Jennifer Garner from the face,
    hair, graceful dimples and sweet smile. Reese Witherspoon is an actress that usually wears black dresses.

    Another issue is that celebrities have more money that the majority of the population so they can afford to change their clothing styles more often than others.
    All this just implies how much we focus of cloths & things we wear.

  15. Just how much folic acid do you need to notice a difference in your hair growth.

    The US National Library of Medicine warns against ingesting
    this petroleum product. But who has the time to go through all that information.

  16. Be honest and accurate – When you fill out each quote you have to be as accurate as you can be.
    If you purchase from a store, should you pay for delivery.
    And of course you will need to look for a home in your new
    city.

  17. When he sells a home, he is generating profit for his job.
    Much depends on property type, location, and use of
    facility. With the single or double row louvered gutter guards,
    it is highly visible and with a telescopic pole and brush assembly long enough to reach two
    and a half stories (longer ones available) the debris can easily be knocked of the front surface of the gutter guard.
    And by the way, you can even pass this property to your children and
    grandchildren if you wish to keep the property. The official number of people killed stands at
    over 2,000 while rescue searches continue and bodies wash ashore.
    This method usually involves providing documented proof to the lender that the delinquent homeowner is
    in a hardship situation and can no longer afford to make payments on their mortgage loan. For the arrangement to be mutually beneficial, the
    right amount of public financial assistance, whether up-front to aid in direct development
    costs or deferred (sometimes in the form of tax or utility credits,
    or back-ended ground lease payments) over time, should be included as a structural
    support of the project so that the consultant will know
    how to correctly structure the P3 arrangement. One of the easiest and safest ways to start gaining real estate investment experience and some spare
    cash for your future deals is by bird-dogging, or in other
    words, providing qualified leads to more accomplished investors.
    If you want a good deal on real estate investment in Uganda,
    you should understand the current trend in home prices;
    analyze the future market prospects of that property before taking steps towards obtaining a mortgage loan. However, the platform offers one of the greatest opportunities
    and higher rates of return in the current volatile economy is to invest in commercial real estate.

  18. Keep the mixture cooled and pat it on your lips as often as
    necessary. Vitamin E is particularly beneficial, promoting healing, good blood circulation, and fortified capillary walls.
    A number of would say that will sometimes they
    rarely find time to rinse their hair.

  19. Where business and personal taxes are concerned, hiring
    a Manhattan CPA can benefit you a great deal when you consider that they have far more
    knowledge about these issues than what most business owners
    and individuals do. This can at times prove to be cost effective option, as you
    have to give them work only as and when needed. You will have a profit of infrastructure along with customers,
    employees, computers and many more if you go for buying a business which is running
    currently.

  20. Yes, fashion trends are referential and recurring, but at the same time
    new ones pop up, allowing us to visually reflect the
    world around us. So, all of them will buy a pair of beautiful chinese embroidered shoes without any hesitant.
    Being a model requires more than just being a pretty face.

  21. The plus however is that it is not Oompa Loompa orange, just a small little hue of it, but not a bad one in the least.
    If the skin is still moist, the color can rub off and even stain clothing.
    Fake Bake Tanning Lotion contains a blend of unique naturally derived tanning ingredients called DHA and Erythulose.
    Spray tanning exposes the individual to the sunless tanning product directly
    and this often means that there is a high exposure to DHA.
    Once you learn how to spray tan, you’ll want to know how to lay
    a good foundation and keep the tan for as long as possible.

    You can show off your midriff and expose your arms and not show nasty white lines (one of the best things about a
    fake tan is that you can easily avoid bikini lines etc).
    Tanning products are not new, but a certainly gaining
    in popularity. The Loreal Self Tanning Spray known as L’Oreal Sublime Bronze Pro Perfect
    Salon Airbrush Self Tanning Mist is a great product.
    Care should be taken while applying the spray to
    ensure that it does not fall on your hands and feet because you can get a white vein like
    look due to the presence of excess wrinkles and creases in these areas.
    The art of appealing to the masses and judges through one’s intelligence, charms
    and beauty is what an individual learns here.

  22. ‘ Propecia is meant to be used in men suffering from male pattern baldness after consulting a doctor.

    A study published in The Journal of Dermatology revealed that chlorine causes discolouration and a change in hair texture.
    It improves your hair’s elasticity, texture and strength.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: